Cull The Herd

by Michelle MacPhearson

This entry is part 3 of 23 in the series 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover

Welcome to Day 3 of the 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover (#31DIMM for short)!

In August of 2009, Stanford University released a study on the productivity of heavy multitaskers.  Here are some choice findings:

[Multitaskers are] suckers for irrelevancy…  Everything distracts them.

[Multitaskers] couldn’t help thinking about the task they weren’t doing.  The high multitaskers are always drawing from all the information in front of them. They can’t keep things separate in their minds.

The low multitaskers did great.  The high multitaskers were doing worse and worse the further they went along… and had difficulty keeping [the tasks] sorted in their brains.”

(I promise not to get all scientific with you every day of the Makeover!)

Multitasking on a new dimensionBut this study illustrates the exact problem we struggle with as entrepreneurs in the internet marketing space.

By splitting your attention to nurturing tens, hundreds, even thousands of sites, projects and streams of income you’re diminishing your ability to focus on, complete and maximize any of them.

Yesterday, you took inventory of all your domains, their current status, earnings and cost to maintain.

Today, you’ll look over your inventory and determine which sites you should let go of and which sites you should keep and revamp throughout the rest of the 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover.

Consider it a “fresh start” – after today’s Makeover tasks, those projects that were mentally weighing you down (“I really should finish adding content to site XYZ…”), not producing and distracting you from the bigger picture will be eliminated.

DAY 03 OBJECTIVE

Determine which projects and domains should be let go of.  Create a plan to get rid of them and implement it!

DAY 03 ASSIGNMENT

Consider your Inventory Spreadsheet from yesterday.  Most likely, there are already a few sites or projects that jump out at you as losers – ones you know just aren’t earning what it costs to keep them.  Highlight those in your spreadsheet with red.

There are likely a few domains or projects that you know you want to keep.  Perhaps they’re big earners for you (obviously, that would make sense to keep those!).  Highlight those in green.

And there are going to be projects that are in the “I dunno” phase.  They’re not earning much, but they’ve got potential, or they just need a little bit more tweaking to get them where you want to be.  Highlight those in yellow.

Here’s an example of a completed spreadsheet:

31dimm-cullLet’s go over the rows and some typical situations you’ll encounter and decisions you’ll be making:

Example.com is getting traffic and earning (although modestly) each month.  We’re guessing it’ll take about 5 more hours of work to complete the site.  In this case, it’s at position #3 for it’s main keyword, and those 5 hours will be devoted to link building to bring the site’s rank higher (and therefore earn more income).  The earnings are pretty low for the amount of traffic it gets, so perhaps we could be monetizing it more effectively too.  It’s marked Yellow because we’re never CERTAIN how much time it’ll take to get our rank to #1, and although it’s covering it’s own costs, it’s not really blowing us out of the water with it’s monthly income.

Example2.com is just not started.  Probably a domain name we bought when we had a really good idea, but we just never got around to it.  It’s going to require a ton of work (maybe that time would be better spent on Example.com above?) and it’s costing us about $1/month to own in domain renewals.  It’s Red because our time could be better spent elsewhere and it’s costing us money and mental energy.

Example3.com is active and it looks like we’ve done everything right.  It’s earning more than it costs to keep each month and doesn’t require maintainence time.  It’s in position #2 for it’s main keyword phrase (and if we spend some time on it perhaps we can take it to #1, that time should be added “Hours to complete.”)  It’s green because it’s working well on its own and earning.

Example4.com isn’t earning nearly enough considering the traffic it’s getting and it’s rank at #1 for it’s main keyword phrase.  It could be a situation where the market simply isn’t comprised of buyers or ad clickers, or it could be that the products that are being offered are not a close enough match to the market.  It’s marked yellow because it’ll need some adjustments to really earn to it’s potential.

With each line in your Inventory spreadsheet classified, go back and look over your GREEN and YELLOW rows.

Remember that sometimes we want to keep hold of things for emotional reasons:

  • I’ve already put in so much time!
  • I’ve spent $XXX to buy the domain and build it!
  • I just really love this idea and wanted it to work!
  • I committed to the project and to not see it through would be another disappointment!

But these emotional reasons for hanging on to projects aren’t helpful to us, just as the Stanford study proved.  They take too much mental energy – even when not working on them – and all our projects suffer as a result.  Look closely at those projects you’ve mentally earmarked as “keepers.”

GET BRUTALLY HONEST!

Are you wanting to keep this project for emotional reasons? Are you attached to it?

Remember, above all, this is a business.  It’s about the bottom line (last I checked, internet marketers like us don’t have angel investors bailing us out whenever we need more cash!).  If a project isn’t cutting it, it’s time to let it go.

And don’t forget that not only does a project need to be earning income for it to make business sense, but it’s got to make sense as far as your time commitment to finish the project and then maintain it in the future.

HASGJLetting go is a little scary, but it’s freeing too.

Free up the time you have to work on productive sites and your mental energy by releasing those projects that are weighing you down.

HOW MANY TO KEEP? WHERE DO I DRAW THE LINE?

This is a question I just can’t answer for you – I know, it’d be a lot easier if I could.

That’s why I asked you to get brutally honest with yourself.

Only you know how much time you have to spend on your business.  Only you know how much passion and motivation you have for a particular project.  Only you know the keyword research and affiliate program intricacies of your particular markets.

All of those factors will go into your decision as to what you keep and what you cull.

Just get real – is it worth my time playing around with this site anymore?  Do I really have the time for this given the other sites with higher earnings?

Update your Inventory Spreadsheet to reflect this brutal, forthright honesty.  You should have a few more red lines now.  That’s ok, it’ll give you the focus you need to work on your green lines.

HOW TO GET RID OF UNPRODUCTIVE SITES

One man’s trash is another man’s treasure, or so the saying goes, right?

Your partially developed domain, or site that’s just not earning up to par can be sold to someone who has the time, resources or motivation to give it the attention it deserves.

The hottest place for selling websites and domains right now is Flippa, it’s a heavily trafficked auction house just for your web properties.

For the best listing, be as complete and honest as you possibly can about your site, it’s traffic and earnings.  People want to know what they’re bidding on and buying!

Look at the “Most Active Listings” and emulate the information they provide potential buyers.  Also notice that many of the “Most Active”  listings also have relatively low starting bids.  Don’t set a starting bid so high no one will take the bite.

Remember, you have nothing to lose and all the freedom, time and mental energy to gain for more lucrative projects.

Also peek at the “Ended Unsold” listings to get an idea of what makes for an unattractive auction, so you don’t make the same mistakes.  Many of the listings there are private (so don’t make your listings private!), have really high starting bids or tediously boring and cryptic titles.

List your RED sites today, because tomorrow we’re going to dive into those sites you left “in the green” and make them over!

ABOUT THE 31 DAY INTERNET MARKETING MAKEOVER

The 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover gives you a step-by-step process, with a new post and instruction every day – and it’s entirely free, no strings attached.

As you complete each days’ steps, you will make substantial and concrete progress in taming your business to make it more manageable, more profitable and MORE FUN!

Fill out the form below and day you’ll receive an email each day with a link to the newest 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover post. You can unsubscribe at any time and I will never, ever, ever share, rent or sell your contact information!

Join the 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover!
First Name *
Primary Email *

You will also want to keep up-to-date with 31 Day IM Makeover happenings through the following channels:

Twitter: Follow @michellem on Twitter

Facebook: Become a fan on Facebook and you’ll get notification when a new post is up

RSS: Subscribe to this blog’s RSS feed to have new posts delivered to your feedreader

The official Twitter hashtag for the 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover is #31DIMM (yes, I know it reads “31 Dim” but that’s kinda funny, right?). You can find other participants by searching Twitter for the hashtag.

Join using the form above and look in your inbox tomorrow for the next step in your Internet Marketing Makeover!

And use the social icons below to share the Makeover on your preferred social network:


Click here for more posts in the 31 Day Internet Marketing Makeover series.

Post to Twitter  Post to Facebook  Post to StumbleUpon

Related posts:

{ 18 comments… read them below or add one }

Jim Munro December 3, 2009 at 10:18 am

Hi Michelle,

Good start. Thanks!

Some of the sites I have are never really “done” in the sense that I usually spend updating them daily/weekly/monthly for current content and/or answering comments and things. How do you rate these type of sites? They may not be the main money-generation site, but may channel to a more specialized site that is the money site, but are still important.

Do many individuals really maintain thousands of sites? I don’t see how that’s possible. Sounds like torture. :)

Reply

Michelle MacPhearson December 3, 2009 at 12:08 pm

@Jim – Maybe estimate how much time they require to maintain monthly, as use that as your metric for comparison.

Yep, some folks do manage thousands! But they’ve usually got staff to handle it too!

Reply

Hulia Hughes December 3, 2009 at 10:45 am

Hi Michelle,
I have noticed that you are using a lot of Flickr images in your blog WITHOUT explicitly giving credit to the photo authors. You should not do that. The photos you are using have Creative Commons license that stipulates that credit be given to the authors of the photos.
Great blog, though! :)
j

Reply

Michelle MacPhearson December 3, 2009 at 12:09 pm

@Hulia – All images are linked to the author and credited thusly.

Reply

Michael December 3, 2009 at 3:35 pm

OK, if multitasking is something to stop and instead focus on one task at a time, why do you have so many things competing for your readers attention going on on this site at the same time?

Reply

Esti Allina-Turnauer December 6, 2009 at 9:27 pm

Where are you looking? I personally did not find the blog post had any distractions. The post itself was very clear and followed a logical development. Maybe you could be more specific, or simply take responsibility for your own distractability?

Reply

Wayne Stanila December 3, 2009 at 4:15 pm

Looking forward to these daily lessons.

Could you show me how to google to check back links to my site?

Thanks,
Wayne

Reply

Drago December 3, 2009 at 5:26 pm

Hi Wayne,
Just type in google – link:yourdomain.com. That should give you all the links Google finds back linking to your site. Same can be done on yahoo and msn.

Reply

kuala lumpur December 3, 2009 at 9:15 pm

Those are really useful tips. And thanks for introducing the Flippa site. I know it will come useful one day.
Yes I have the problem of too many sites and too little time to do them. I currently have 3 sites but only working on one. Guess I’ll need to prune the other 2 as it is costing me money just lying idle.

However, on my active site, I have quite a general site concept and thus has a hugh potential – but of course needs a hugh amount of investment in time to get it seriously driving traffic. I believe your 31 day makeover will help me get there.

Reply

Tim December 4, 2009 at 11:17 am

Hi Michelle,
First of all, Thanks! This is a problem I’ve grappled with now I have a means of objectively solving it.
I’ve set up 6 websites this year. One I set up and let sit – amazingly – when I looked at it after about 2 months was a PR2! I make no money from it and it and it gets about 10 unique visitors a day. I don’t know if I should just sell it? I have other more productive sites but, they are not even rated – have no PR. Peculiar?
Thanks again,
Tim

Reply

Michelle MacPhearson December 4, 2009 at 3:07 pm

@Tim – Whether you should sell the other sites is dependent on how much time they actually require to work with and how much time you have in your day to work on your business.

PR really doesn’t matter, in that PR alone w/o traffic or sales is no reason to hold on to a domain.

PR can be a factor in the bids you get should you decide to sell a site on Flippa – having PR, or a higher PR, is generally more attractive to a potential buyer.

Reply

Parka December 4, 2009 at 3:58 pm

Passion is key I think. However, passion without relevance is useless. Being a lone voice in the wilderness is pretty pointless if you’re trying to make money from that particular idea. Trying to convince people to buy into something they don’t want seems like an up-hill battle, no matter how good you are at candy-coating. Passion is contagious but I guess the trick is doing proper research before deciding on how to channel your passion..

Reply

Grace December 4, 2009 at 7:53 pm

so true. i spend most of the day thinking about the tasks i haven’t done, the contents that should’ve been added to my other site, etc. in the end i’m spreading myself too thin without accomplishing anything.

Reply

Mitchell Allen December 6, 2009 at 9:53 am

I skipped the spreadsheet part because none of my sites make money. They’re all subsidized by client fees :)

However, the fact remains that I spend too much time agonizing over some of them. My problem is that it is so easy to set up a blog that most of my sites are based on WordPress. As a result, I feel like I need to add content periodically. I rarely do.

I appreciate this exercise. I am going to consider dumping 90% of these turkeys.

I don’t consider myself to be entirely hamstrung by the criteria that you set forth at the beginning of of the series. However, having recently back-slid into the miasma of opportunism (and then crawled out again), I feel that this exercise will teach me some new habits to protect my new-found focus on two main projects.

Thanks, Michelle!

Mitch

Reply

Kirsten December 7, 2009 at 1:46 pm

Thank you Michelle for the helpful guide and useful spreadsheet.

Reply

Ian McGuire December 23, 2009 at 2:32 pm

Random question: how are you getting the dropshadows on your screen captures like above? I’ve seen the feature all over the place recently.

Reply

Michelle MacPhearson December 23, 2009 at 2:37 pm

@Ian – SnagIt.

Reply

Ian McGuire December 23, 2009 at 2:44 pm

Brilliant, thanks!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post: Take Your Internet Marketing Inventory

Next post: Upgrade Day!